Hellthy Junk Food is coming to Prime Video
Video + recipeCopycatDesserts

4 Ways to Butterbeer

So second time going to Harry Potter World, we learned that there are several different types of Butterbeer… who knew? We decided to make four of the most popular versions such as Frozen, Hot, Ice Cream & Regular. There’s also a fudge and potted cream… maybe for another day…

4 Ways to Butterbeer
Jump to recipe
The recipe

Base Recipe

Serves1
CourseBeverage
CuisineHarry Potter
Total time30 mins

Ingredients

Butterbeer Catalyst

Whipped Topping

Instructions

  1. Catalyst

    In a small sauce pot, add 2 Cups Brown sugar & ¼ Cup Water and bring the mixture to a boil.

  2. Add 12 Tbsp Butter, 1 tsp Cider Vinegar, 1 tsp Salt, 1 tsp Rum Extract and ½ Cup Heavy Cream and mix.

  3. Let this mixture chill

  4. Whipped Topping

    In a kitchen aid stand mixer, whisk 2 Cups Heavy Cream with 2 Tbsp Butterbeer Catalyst & ½ tsp Rum Extract

  5. Whisk on high speed until the mixture thickens

Made it? Tag #hellthyjunkfood, Julia wants to see how it turned out.
Share on Instagram

More recipes from this video

Recipe 2

Normal Butterbeer

Serves 1

  1. Fill ⅛ of the glass with the catalyst

  2. Add the rest with Cream Soda

  3. Top with whipped topping

Recipe 3

Hot Butterbeer

Serves 1

  1. Fill ⅛ of the glass with the catalyst

  2. Add the rest with Cream Soda

  3. Microwave for 1 minute

  4. Top with whipped topping

Recipe 4

Frozen Butterbeer

Serves 1

  1. Take a 16 oz plastic bottle of A&W Cream Soda and shake it up vigorously

  2. Place the Cream Soda & drinking glass in the freezer for 3-1/2 hours

  3. Open the lid, and quickly close it, which will cause a chemical reaction freezing all the liquid in the plastic bottle

  4. Fill ⅛ of the glass with the catalyst

  5. Add the rest with the frozen Cream Soda

  6. Top with whipped topping

Recipe 5

Ice Cream Butterbeer

Serves 1

  1. Take 1 Liter of Cream Soda and boil it on high heat until it reduces down to 1 Cup (approximately 30 minutes)

  2. In a large bowl, add 1 Cup Heavy Cream, 1 Cup Milk, 1 Cup Reduced Cream Soda, 7 oz Sweetened Condensed Milk, 1 tsp Rum Extract & 2 Tbsp Catalyst

  3. Whisk mixture together and refrigerate

  4. Once cool, churn it in ice cream machine for 20 minutes and freeze covered for a few hours

  5. Scoop out your ice cream, drizzle on some additional catalyst and top with whipped topping

DIY Chili’s Mozzarella Sticks

Copycat
Nov 24, 2024

DIY Burger King Purple Wednesday Burger

Copycat
Oct 19, 2024

DIY Wendy’s TOP SECRET Kollab Sauce

Copycat
Oct 13, 2024

DIY Barbecue Thors Hammer

Copycat
Sep 14, 2024
The newsletter

New recipes and episodes, straight to your inbox.

Premiere news, new episodes and the occasional food hack worth knowing. One email a week, tops.