Hellthy Junk Food is coming to Prime Video
Video + recipeCopycatFan Requests

How to Make the ENTIRE Shake Shack Menu πŸ”

We broke down every menu item from Shake Shack to make them ourselves.

We Eat THE ENTIRE Shake Shack Menu

How to Make the ENTIRE Shake Shack Menu πŸ”
Jump to recipe
The recipe

How to Make the ENTIRE Shake Shack Menu πŸ”

In times of hunger you may be like us in craving Shake Shack. This burger chain is famous for its thoughtful proteins and practices but also their incredible taste. These recipes are antibiotic and hormone-free but also bring a smack in the face of flavor. Below we've broken down the ingredients and directions to make the entire menu. Feel free to pull one or two recipes out to try or give it all a go!y! Stay hellthy, friends.

Ingredients

Shake Sauce

Buttermilk Herb Mayo

Chicken Marinade

Chicken Breading

Stuffed Portobellos

Cheese Sauce

Instructions

Things you'll need
Crinkle CutterDeep FryerElectric GriddleCast Iron SkilletPlastic WrapParchment PaperHJF Cutting BoardHJF ApronBelow are our recipes to place into your stand for the portable Five Guys. Let us know in the comments which recipes you love and give us a heads up what copy cat recipes you'd like to see us cook up next.
  1. Begin prepping your recipes 1 day in advance. Clean all vegetables and produce. Slice Tomatoes, Dice Onion, Prepare Lettuce.

  2. In a small bowl mix together the ingredients for the Shake Sauce. Set in the refrigerator

  3. In a small bowl mix together the ingredients for the Buttermilk Herb Mayo. Set in the refrigerator.

  4. Precook bacon on a tinfoil lined backing sheet. Place in a cool oven and bake for 30 minutes at 350Β°F.

  5. Clean and cut off excess fat, and tenderize chicken. Cut into patties for the chicken sandwich or into nuggets. In a large bowl whisk together the marinade ingredients. Place the chicken in the bowl. Cover and set in the refrigerator overnight.

  6. Clean and cut potatoes into crinkle cut fries using the crinkle cutter. Set fries into an ice water bath. Dry on a rack or paper towel. Deep fry at 350Β°F for 2 1/2 minutes. Set to cool and then aside in the refrigerator. (refry until golden when ready to serve)

  7. Prepare the stuffed mushrooms by cleaning and then pulling out the stems. Place on a paper towel lined microwavable safe plate. Microwave for 2 minutes. Cool. Gently press mushrooms in between two pieces of parchment paper until thin. Place a mushroom top side down atop plastic wrap. Mix together grated cheeses in a bowl. Put a heaping tablespoon of cheese mixture in the center. Place a second mushroom right side up on top. Wrap the plastic around to hold the mushrooms together. Bread in flour, egg, then panko. When ready to serve Preheat the deep fryer to 350Β°F and deep fry for 4 minutes or until cheese starts to come out.

  8. In a large bowl, paper bag, or batter pro combine the breading mixture ingredients. Take chicken out of the marinade and place in the dry mixture to coat. Double coat by placing floured chicken back into the marinade and then back into the dry mixture again.

  9. At this point you are prepared to start making burgers. Press out 4 oz pucks of beef on parchment paper. Heat a cast iron skillet or pan to medium high heat. Use a burger press to press pucks into patties on the skillet. Cook until blood spools in the middle and flip. Add cheese.

  10. Brush melted butter on buns and toast on the griddle until golden brown.

  11. To build spread Shake Sauce on the top bun, place lettuce, and then two slices of tomato. On the bottom bun place the burger. Copy the builds above for the other sandwiches from the menu.

Made it? Tag #hellthyjunkfood, Julia wants to see how it turned out.
Share on Instagram

DIY Chili’s Mozzarella Sticks

Copycat
Nov 24, 2024

DIY Burger King Purple Wednesday Burger

Copycat
Oct 19, 2024

DIY Wendy’s TOP SECRET Kollab Sauce

Copycat
Oct 13, 2024

DIY Barbecue Thors Hammer

Copycat
Sep 14, 2024
The newsletter

New recipes and episodes, straight to your inbox.

Premiere news, new episodes and the occasional food hack worth knowing. One email a week, tops.